Tim Ritenour ([info]timmy_ritz) wrote,
@ 2006-04-13 09:56:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current mood: confused

The Da Vinci Code . . . I don't get the fuss
So obviously the Da Vinci code is the biggest book since sliced bread in America. It's been on the New York Top Ten since it's release years ago. That is a monstrous accomplishment.

Now that I'm taking the time to read it though, I'm kind of dissapointed. I find the book to be slow, plodding, and preachy. Which is odd, since I loved Dan Brown's first novel in the series, Angels and Demons. I've heard people say that if you read Da Vinci first, than Angels and Demons seems lesser in your eyes, and the oppisate must hold true as well I guess.

The whole science vs. religion and secret history of the Illuminati in Angels and Demons fascinated me. The whole Holy Grail and Jesus has a lovechild thing doesn't. And I'm not even offended by the idea, just its lame execution. Maybe it's because I've actually done research into the historical background of biblical texts (thank you college), but it seems obvious to me that Brown is setting up some paper thin arguments and cherry picking quotes out of context to support the mystery of the novel, which is offputting. It's hard to get lost in the fictional world when you see inaccuracies everywhere you look.

I'm halfway through the book right now, and I think I'm just going to stop altogether. I never do that. I'm not even all that interested in the movie now.

I usually pride myself on having a good idea about what works in mainstream culture and what doesn't, and on the surface I guess I can see why Da Vinci got so much press, but I'm shocked so many people actually enjoyed it. It's pretty sucky writing I think.




(Post a new comment)


[info]axelicious
2006-04-13 10:28 am UTC (link)
You know, I liked this book. So I have to disagree with you. Mind you, I don't think it should win any pulitzer prizes for literature, and my views on religion don't come into play since I have none to speak of. The book, on it surface is simply a mystery novel, but it's food for the lizard brain. It provides you with subtle little challenges (how challenging they are varies; I found them quite easy after the first couple, once I got my brain thinking) and these little victories or defeats encourage the reader to keep going. I don't agree that the writing is bad. While there has been better writing, there certainly has been worse. And the execution is what makes it so enjoyable. The layout, that's what get's people. The topic is just bread to fill out the meal. This could have been about corruption at a major corporation, or some other lightning rod. The excution is the genius. The fact that he choose something like religion to tie it together is just flash.

Of course, I read this first, then started Angels and Demons...I put it down, too. I don't know why. It just didn't grab me. If that's the case, it certainly is an odd phenomenon.

(Reply to this)


[info]mycroftca
2006-04-13 10:58 am UTC (link)
I suspected as much...

(Reply to this)


[info]rafael607
2006-04-13 02:08 pm UTC (link)
yeah, this is odd. i feel like i'm one of 3 people on the entire planet that hasn't read the da vinci code. and it's not like i'm against reading it or anything, but by now i've heard people talking about it for like 3 years, so i basically already know the story, and the movie'll be out soon enough anyway...

i do feel left out though. is there a cliff's notes version yet?...

(Reply to this)


[info]sugarbabiedoll
2006-04-13 04:28 pm UTC (link)
I was going to say. . .before you commented on it. . .I head the same thing about which book you read first. After I read "DaVinci" and loved it, someone told me to read "Angels and Demons" because it's "much better." But before I picked it up, someone else told me I'd be disapppointed because if I liked "DaVinci" and read it first, then "Angels and Demons" doesn't compare. And the people who like "Angels and Demons" a lot are the ones who read that book first.

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…